Why I Support Gay Marriage


March 28, 2013 by liebestropfchen

So let’s be real here…discussion of homosexuality is everywhere right now. Which I think is wonderful! Why? Because I have long wanted people to stop ignoring the discussion of something as important as sexual orientation, especially how it relates to marriage and religion.

Obviously, I am going to be stating my opinion here, and I hope my readers will accept this as an educated opinion instead of pure condemnation. However, I do speak from the perspective of someone who has had many gay friends throughout my lifetime, and my life has been full of absolute joy for having these friendships. I have learned so much about love from them. There’s actually a running joke in my family about the number of gay men I dated when I was younger (long before any of them came out), which some may find odd…but I find beautiful, and I will explain why a little later.

On the flip side, I used to be married to a person who had pure hatred for homosexuals that oozed from his every orifice like dystentery. I have seen firsthand how ugly bigotry is, and no amount of acceptance in my heart can counteract the blind hatred people use as justification for suppressing the rights of others. Despite that reality, I feel I cannot remain silent on this issue, because the only way we have a chance in combatting this hatred is to educate society that bigotry NEVER justifies the bigot’s root cause.


The same arguments I hear today for opposing gay marriage are as ridiculous as the ones used in my grandparents’ generation for opposing interracial marriage. The children will grow up confused, they say. The children need a mom and a dad, they say. The children will be made fun of, they say. Accepting gay marriage will cause all of society to run amuck with loose morals, they say. This, from a society that glorifies the Kardashians and does not condemn Chris Brown for beating the shit out of Rihanna?


I think we have bigger problems with “immorality” than two men or two women who love each other enough to raise children together and share equal access to health benefits that heterosexual couples have.

I didn’t used to be so outspoken about my support for the gay community, partially because I was so concerned with making my own marriage work that I had to choose my battles carefully. What I have come to realize six years after my divorce is that I chose the wrong battles. Between the ages of 18 and 27 I had done everything according to what my parents and a Christian society expected of a “good Christian girl” – I dated a man for nearly 7 years before we got married, all the while keeping my mouth shut and letting the man run the relationship, preparing myself for a life of wifedom and motherhood, conforming my opinions to match his (lest I be yelled at for an hour and called an “idiot”), and deciding to stay quiet when he spoke poorly of my homosexual friends, because I could never quite find the right argument in support of the gay community without having the Bible thrown back in my face.

It’s hard to argue with a 2,000-year-old book that encourages men to refrain from sleeping next to an “unclean” (menstruating) woman. That shit is relevant today, and the marketing geniuses at Kotex can’t pretend otherwise.


One day, after I had had enough of being shushed for my opinions that differed from the Bible, I finally understood that I didn’t need justification for what I believed, because I knew in my heart that love was always the right answer. Love exists in the heart. Love doesn’t exist on paper, in a book, written by a generation of men who didn’t believe women had any value in society (let alone anyone who lived outside the standard rules of conformity). Love doesn’t need justification, it only needs an avenue with which to express itself.

Opponents of gay marriage champion the notion that the “sanctity of marriage” is in jeopardy. Really what they’re saying is, they support my heterosexual ability to exercise my right getting married to someone who had zero respect for me as an educated woman, so he could emotionally abuse me every day. I didn’t clean the house well enough, I didn’t cook enough, it upset him sooooo that I made more money than he did, and he finally raised his fist to me when I wasn’t obedient to him anymore. Given that when I left that man, my church didn’t make me feel welcome at all, what value has our society actually placed on the traditional marriage anyway? An abusive heterosexual marriage is of better value than a respectful homosexual marriage?

Based on my own experience, those who speak on the sanctity of marriage typically have an antiquated viewpoint of gender roles in a marriage to begin with, so I’m not about to accept that argument as relevant to a post-feminist society.

I didn’t need a piece of paper to tell me that I had no business being in a loveless marriage that left me abused and neglected. It was my mistake to believe that living by society’s “traditional” standards would bring me happiness. Years later, I AM actually happy…because I am living to my own standards. That marriage license I got from the State of Ohio didn’t amount to a hill of beans in proving that love exists at all.

Human nature leads us to seek our soul mate, our desires, our fulfillment. We can make mistakes or hit the jackpot when it comes to finding love – but that is driven by human nature alone, not by a piece of paper from the government. Yet I say this as a privileged person, because I am a heterosexual. I can get married again, I have merely chosen not to. My gay friends who have found the one they want to spend their lives with do not have the choice at all – they must simply cohabitate with no formally state-recognized financial marriage benefits. To be honest, there are a lot of laws that recognize domestic partnerships, but that’s just the lipstick on a pig hooplah. It’s still not equality.

Why do we need the government to sign a hall pass for us to walk down the aisle at all? Laws like that merely state that the government feels heterosexual citizens have “better judgment” at declaring they are choosing a viable partner to raise a family with…but I think we can all agree Honey Boo Boo destroys that logic.


What does prove the existence of love is the gesture one human can make toward another in the form of a kiss, a touch, or in saying “I want to spend every day with you.”

Only the privileged can point the finger of judgment because they happen to be on the “right” side of social acceptance. Many of those who condemn homosexuality have never thought of what it would be like if the coin were flipped, and society deemed heterosexuality to be reprehensible. Ask a gay man or woman to go on a date with someone of the opposite sex? It happens all the time in high schools and colleges across America. However, the mere suggestion of asking a homophobic man or woman to go on a date with someone of the same sex may have you looking down the barrel of a shotgun. Why is that?

I was blessed to be raised by two parents that preached acceptance and love at any cost. I will always be grateful for that, because when I became a Christian at the age of 18, I already had it settled in my heart that conformity would never come at the expense of love or compassion. I suppose that’s why my attendance at church ended when my abusive marriage did.

My friends and family playfully tease me about having several boyfriends who are now openly gay, and for one in particular they ask me, “How in the hell did you NOT know he was gay???” After conforming to the church life, I let the teasing get under my skin, and I started to think maybe there was something wrong with me that caused it. That’s what organized religion did to me, it made me question my own heart. That’s not a good thing.

One day, though, it hit me…there wasn’t something wrong with me at all. There was something RIGHT about me that caused gay men to be comfortable being themselves with me, as much as they could be. When a young man or woman is not ready to tell the world they are gay, but they still want the happiness of experiencing dates, homecoming dances, and proms, they must find someone they feel comfortable enough with that they know they can be themselves without a microscope to point out how they are “different”.

Honestly, of all the school dances I went to in my teens, the one at which I had the most fun was my junior prom. My boyfriend at the time, Ryan, was so comfortable in his flamboyance, that it made me comfortable in my nerdiness. We danced our asses off, we vogued, we laughed, and I felt a lot of love for that boy. Looking back it wasn’t a romantic kind of love, it was something much different. Deep down I knew he was gay (we all did) but he and I had a special connection, in that we didn’t feel like there was any pressure to conform to the social norms of teenage sexuality. I was terrified of dating because I was so inexperienced, and he was terrified of dating because of the obvious.

Apparently he sensed that I would accept him for who he was, so he felt comfortable asking me on dates. No one should have to miss out on movies, dinners, proms, or the feeling of holding someone’s hand simply because they’re afraid someone will find out who they really are. Ryan deserved happiness then as much as anyone else, and he still does today.

That story isn’t unique to Ryan. Love has so many layers, and it can differ from relationship to relationship. Those who wish to define marriage as “between a man and a woman” seem to believe deep down that if gay marriage weren’t allowed, homosexuality wouldn’t exist. Or if gay marriage IS allowed, homosexuality will somehow become an epidemic. Let me tell you, that is a sad excuse for an argument in a losing battle. Love can be mistaken for respect, love can come and go, and love can even turn into hatred…but love cannot be hidden with the absence of a piece of government paper. Homosexuality is not a choice, and gay men and women should not be denied equality in their ability to declare love that would exist regardless.

The sanctity of marriage is only as good as the participants involved, and at this point I think we can stand to benefit from allowing those who are beating down doors to be able to marry the ones they love.


14 thoughts on “Why I Support Gay Marriage

  1. Don Ostertag says:

    AMEN! Heard all the same arguments back in the racial Civil Rights movement.that bigots are using against same-sex marriages.

  2. I agree that love is between 2 people. But if your in a bad marriage, it’s just that, a bad marriage, regardless if it was a gay or straight one. I still believe “marriage” as an institution is between a “man and a woman”. Call me old fashioned. I don’t consider myself religious, but I still like to uphold and respect that sanctity as the way a church would define it, between a “man and a woman”. I have nothing against civil unions, contracts, etc. So what is formally state recognized financial marriage benefits? I thought it was just a piece of paper? If its a matter of equal rights, that should certainly be addressed and I agree that all persons should have equal rights under our constitution. But maybe trying to force America to accept gay marriage as a way to further gay equality isn’t the right avenue or approach? Now, they are trying to call it a “civil rights violation” (See my latest post) I also have gay friends and accept everyone for who they are. Everyone should have equality regardless of race or gender. With that said, I still think marriage is a sacred institution between a man and a woman. That’s just my opinion and I respect your opinion too.

    • I can understand your position. Speaking from a religious standpoint, I can see how the definition of marriage would be sacred and honored by biblical standards. However, our laws are not governed by the Bible. if our government is to define marriage based on biblical conditions, then our government would be respecting an establishment of religion. I fully believe our government should not even be involved in any marriage, heterosexual or homosexual. I think we should all have civil unions.

    • I’m glad we can both be respectful in our difference of opinion. It’s refreshing! Thanks for reading and commenting 🙂

  3. Jnana Hodson says:

    As I read Scripture, what I see emerging is a desire for monogamy. The instances of bigamy never work, there’s ALWAYS the wife who’s having all the children and the wife who’s the beloved, the promised helpmeet, who typically has difficulty having children. And all of the conflict in between. So marriage, in light of the “suitable opposite,” is not about children, but about a relationship of mutuality — a kind of equality that is possible only one-on-one. In the end, we have Paul arguing it’s better to marry than burn with desire, but he leaves unanswered the question, what if heterosexual marriage does not end the burning?
    You can fill in all of the chapter-and-verse references, but I suspect you’ll find support for your own experiences. And for those of your faithful friends and companions along the way.

  4. In my life, I have known far too many people who were gay. I say “far too many” because they were very conflicted and unhappy if they were closeted, or ostracized and beaten if they were out.
    Even now, in too many places, gays, lesbians, transgenders, and bisexuals (my gay friends called them “greedy”) are risking their lives by being who they are.
    I can’t say I was ever in the situation of a failed marriage; my wife and I have been married for almost thirty years, most of them happy. Even so, I realize that she and I are not the average; we have worked at it, and we realize that working at it is not the norm in today’s disposable culture.
    My main argument in favor of marriage equality is this: Why not let homosexuals marry? Let them experience the same disappointment and anguish the rest of us do!
    As to “religion”, I am a recovering Catholic, and a relaxed agnostic. (I don’t know anything for sure… if *you* do, fine… just don’t force your thinking on me.)
    Let’s follow the Constitution, not the Bible… after all, as one Congresscritter was told, “You put your hand on the Bible and swore to uphold the Constitution, not the other way around!”

    • Yes!!! I love that last quote, that’s brilliant!
      I am so glad you agree, and congratulations to you on nearly 30 years with your wife! That does take a lot of work, and both have to be willing to compromise. I think that’s the root of the issue: marriage is not a unique concept to religion, so why should we let one religion define who can marry? Hopefully one day we can all agree on equality. 🙂

  5. storiesbyfrances says:

    I think you are right when you say that love is between two people. And I strongly support gay marriage. Why the hell not? They love each other, what´s the big deal? I was actually the “best woman” at my uncle´s wedding. He married his partner and I saw nothing wrong in that. They have been married for seven years now, they still love each other, they have a cat called Idefix and when you see them together, you simply can´t be against gay marriage anymore.
    So, well-spoken. I like this post very much.

    • Thank you so much! I think it’s wonderful to hear real stories like your uncles :). When you see the happiness, it breaks my heart that people want to ban the equality of marriage.

  6. sophist6 says:

    Perfectly and beautifully put! Thank you for sharing your story and congratulations on finding your strength. I wish you nothing but happiness and truly thank you for your support!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: